Hindu University of America Logo

Hindu University of America

Menu

BECOME A FRIEND
Give to HUA
Login to LMS
Hindu University of America Logo

Hindu University of America

Menu

FAQ

BECOME A FRIEND
Give to HUA
Login to LMS
BECOME A FRIEND
Give to HUA
Login to LMS

Menu

  • About HUA
    • About HUA
    • President’s Message
    • Goals & Objectives
    • Learning Outcomes
    • Mission & Vision
    • Values
    • Ethos And Culture
    • Our Promise
    • Team
    • Partners
    • Heritage
  • Academics
    • Academics
    • Divisions
    • Programs
    • Areas of Study
    • Courses
    • Faculty
    • Credit Hours
    • Academic Calendar
  • Ayurveda College
  • Admissions
    • Admissions
    • Contact
    • Apply
    • Conversion Formula
    • Credit Transfer
    • Tuition and Fees
    • Scholarships
  • Advancement
    • Advancement
    • Director’s Message
    • Giving to HUA
    • Giving Categories
    • Sustenance Funds
    • Capital Funds
    • Endowment Funds
    • Donor Recognition
    • Legacy Gift Guidelines
  • Activities
    • Videos
    • Webinars
    • Events
    • Photos
  • Blog
  • Login
    • Calendar
    • Drive
    • Chat
    • Meet
Latest Blog Raising Hindu Children in a Polarized America
Annual Giving Campaign - 2025-2026 is under way. Donate today by Clicking Here, and help us reach our goal.
So far $1,248,668 has been raised out of a target of $ 3 Million. Click Here to donate today and help us reach our goal.
Close button icon for closing popups
Hindu University of America Logo

Hindu University of America

  • About HUA
          • About HUA
          • President’s Message
          • Goals & Objectives
          • Learning Outcomes
          • Mission & Vision
          • Values
          • Ethos And Culture
          • Our Promise
          • Team
          • Partners
          • Heritage
        • Man in white doing yoga pose at ancient stone temple ruins
        • Learn more about HUA

        • Legacy Gift
        • Donate Today

  • Academics
          • Academics
          • Divisions
          • Programs
          • Areas of Study
          • Courses
          • Faculty-old
          • Credit Hours
          • Academic Calendar
        • Indian students using laptop with Academics page on screen
        • Explore programs and courses

        • A group of 5 young adults sitting with laptops & phones in campus setting
        • Browse our course catalog

  • Ayurveda
  • Admissions
          • Admissions
          • Contact
          • Apply
          • Conversion Formula
          • Credit Transfer
          • Tuition and Fees
          • Scholarships
        • Students
        • Learn more about our admissions process

        • Legacy Gift
        • Apply Now

  • Advancement
          • Advancement
          • Director’s Message
          • Giving to HUA
          • Giving Categories
          • Sustenance Funds
          • Capital Funds
          • Endowment Funds
          • Donor Recognition
          • Legacy Gift Guidelines
        • View of planet Earth from space showing Indian subcontinent
        • Learn about giving to HUA

        • Night view of Ganga river with illuminated ghats and buildings
        • Give to HUA

  • Activities
          • Videos
          • Webinars
          • Events
          • Photos
        • A group of men standing in a room during HUA gathering or event
        • Five men standing together at HUA event, including a swami in orange robes
  • Blog
  • Login
          • Calendar
          • Drive
          • Chat
          • Meet
        • A group of 5 young adults sitting with laptops & phones in campus setting
        • Access HUA Email

        • Indian students using laptop with Academics page on screen
        • Access HUA LMS

Course Details

Home / Course / Distortions in Indian Historiography

Distortions in Indian Historiography

$400.00

Register for Course

Course Code:

HAM4301

Credit Hours:

2

Course Level:

400

Area of Study:

History and Method

Course Description

HAM4301 – This course traces the distortions in the historiography of medieval and modern India, discernible since the Independence of India. Students will learn about the historical background, key events and trends that remain influential today. In particular, we will take a close look at the phenomenon of “Negationism” or the systematic and mostly willful denial of facts of history. It will also evaluate the scholarly and political impact of the various forms of history manipulation and the prospects for their correction. The literature on the Left's willful distortion of communal history in India is limited: S.L. Bhyrappa, Sita Ram Goel, K.S. Lal; Koenraad Elst; Arun Shourie; Meenakshi Jain, D.K Chakrabarti. By contrast, the so-called secularist literature on Hindu communal historiography is plentiful but extremely repetitive: Sarvepalli Gopal, Gyanendra Pandey, AG Noorani and many other academics and journalists, both Indian and foreign. Since we are specifically interested in how this phenomenon impacts contemporary political discourse and practice, we will concentrate on the former but will also take cognizance of a sample of the latter. We will also remain alert to the possibility that the attempt to diagnose the errors in historiography can themselves introduce new kinds of history distortion.

Distortions in Indian Historiography
Apply for Program
Enroll In Program
Scholarships
Ask Us A Question
Express Interest

Program of Study

This course is part of the following programs:

  • Community Education Program (CEP)
  • Community Education Program (CEP)

Division

Community Education Division

Required / Core / Elective:

Elective

Prerequisites:

Admission into a Program of Study

Semester / Quarter System:

Quarter

Number of Weeks:

11

Semester / Quarter Offered:

Fall 2021

Days of the Week:

Every Sunday

Time:

12 noon – EST to 2 pm – EST (2 hours per Class session)

Start Date:

October 10, 2021

End Date:

December 19, 2021

Faculty

Koenraad Elst

Koenraad Elst obtained his doctorate in Oriental Philology & History from the Catholic University of Leuven (Belgium) in 1998, based on his MA degrees in Sinology, Indo-Iranian Studies and Philosophy, and a research stay at Banaras Hindu University.
read more

Koenraad.Elst@hua.edu

Course Learning Objectives

In this course, students will be able to:

  • Evaluate Facts, Distortions, Narratives, and Motives.
  • Recognize ‘Negationism’ as a phenomenon and its consequences
  • Explore Case Studies such as the Ram Janmabhoomi Issue.
  • Assess if the Hindu experience can be characterized as a Holocaust or Genocide.
  • Reflect on the prospects for reconstructing Hindu history without biases at either end
Distortions in Indian Historiography

Featured Testimonial

Course Content

The central argument of the course will be made by a close study of key texts produced by denialist historians and their critics. We will examine modern historiography before Indira Gandhi by stalwarts like Jadunath Sarkar and R.C. Majumdar. Though generally honest and consistent with the then prevailing international standards, it was the object of the “secularist” historians’ ire, mainly for taking the communal dimension of Indian history seriously and for promoting the idea of India’s historical unity.

This Hindu-centered idea of India had been taken in his stride even by Jawaharlal Nehru but would subsequently become a battleground both in India and around the world. From the 1970s onwards, historiography became ideologically streamlined in a “secularist” sense. We look into the dramatis personae (S Nurul Hasan, P.N. Haksar, R.S. Sharma, Romila Thapar, Irfan Habib, et al.), their motivation and methods, and the resulting distortions of the historical record.

This approach has remained dominant till today, unchallenged even by the present Indian government. It can often be characterized as having the typical elements of a grand but little-questioned conspiracy theory. Finally, we highlight the handful of critical publications that have nonetheless been devoted to this trend.

Course Structure

There will be a minimum of 1 contact hour with one or more faculty every week. The class is structured in a way that promotes discussion and debate based on self-study and reflection each week. While the content being discussed in each class will be concluded within 90 minutes, the discussion time will be free format and can continue for an additional 30 minutes maximum.

During the course, students will be required to submit one or two short essays. They need not be academic quality papers – but should be based on students’ self-reflection on what they have learned and assimilated so far.  Selected essays may qualify for being published on the University’s website.

X

Distortions in Indian Historiography

$400.00

Clear

Share:

Browse course catalog
Hindu University of America | HUA

Be Part of The HUA Community

Sign-up for HUA communications

Hindu University of America

Main Campus:

  • Pine Lake Retreat Center,
  • 21725 FL-33,
  • Groveland, FL 34736

Administrative Office:

  • 5200 Vineland Rd #125
    Orlando, FL 32811
  • 407 545 5057
  • 407-205-2118
  • info@hua.edu
  • Tax ID / EIN: 59-2977691
Links
  • About HUA
  • President’s Message
  • Goals & Objectives
  • Learning Outcomes
  • Mission & Vision
  • Values
  • Ethos And Culture
  • Our Promise
  • Team
  • Partners
  • Heritage
  • About HUA
  • President’s Message
  • Goals & Objectives
  • Learning Outcomes
  • Mission & Vision
  • Values
  • Ethos And Culture
  • Our Promise
  • Team
  • Partners
  • Heritage
Social
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn

Be Part of The HUA Community

Sign-up for our free webinars

HUA Mitra

AI Mitra
Namaste! How can I assist you today?
Mitra! Ask me anything!
1
Cart
  • Your cart is empty! Return to shop
Checkout - $0.00
  • 0
  • 1
Community Education Program
Please click on the link below to enroll into the Distortions in Indian Historiography Program or the appropriate phase.

On the program page, there are multiple payment plan options to choose from.

Community Education Program

Distortions in Indian Historiography

Animated loading spinner icon in orange on white background

Courses in the Program

  • SAN5101 Vedic Sciences Foundations
  • SAN5102 Vyakarana 01
  • SAN5103 Sahitya I – Landscape
  • SAN5104 Veda I – Introduction to Vedas
  • SAN6101 Nyaya Vaisesika Basic
  • SAN6102 Vyakarana II
  • SAN6103 Sahitya II – Padya
  • SAN6104 Vedas II – Rgveda
  • SAN6105 Yoga Basic
  • SAN7101 Nyaya Vaiseshika Advanced
  • SAN7102 Vyakarana III
  • SAN7103 Sahitya III – Nataka
  • SAN7104 Veda III – Yajurveda-Samaveda
  • SAN7105 Ayurveda Basic
  • SAN7106 Mimasa Basic
  • SAN7107 Jyotisha Basic
  • SAN8101 Term Project
  • SAN8102 Vyakarana IV
  • SAN8103 Sahithya IV – Gadya and Campu
  • SAN8104 Veda IV – Atharva Veda
  • SAN8105 Yoga Advanced
  • SAN8106 Mimasa Advanced
  • SAN8107 Jyotisha Advanced
  • SAN8108 Ayurveda Advanced
  • SAN8109 Vedanta Basic
  • SAN8110 Vedanta Advanced
Animated loading spinner icon in orange on white background
Animated loading spinner icon in orange on white background